What’s The Difference Between a Heat Pump and a Furnace?

Suter Air > Blog > What’s The Difference Between a Heat Pump and a Furnace?

What’s The Difference Between a Heat Pump and a Furnace?

Did your heating system fail last fall? So with winter on the way, it is time to get a new heating system installed at your place by calling experts for your heating services in The Villages, FL

However, while deciding which heating system to opt for their home, many homeowners tend to get confused. Keep reading the article to know the difference between a furnace and a heat pump and which is a better choice for your place. 


Furnaces are something that most homeowners know about and prefer the most. The heat generated by a furnace burns organic gas or oil before discharging it into your home. While earlier people considered furnaces inefficient, recent technological advancements have improved efficiency to the point where some models are up to 98 percent, meaning only 2% of the forced air escapes. 

In addition, nowadays you can also invest in electric-powered furnaces and if you have natural gas routes near your home and is also a good option for your home. Installing a furnace to supplement your air conditioning system instead of a standby heating system like a heat pump can save your budget.

Heat Pumps 

Heating pumps, unlike furnaces, do not use energy or create heat. Instead, they extricate heat from the outside air and blow it into the house using power and coolant. Furthermore, in the summer, a heat pump can work the other way to cool your home by extracting warm air. A heat pump’s effectiveness can reach 300 percent because it uses electricity to relocate heat. 

When working at peak capacity, one unit of electrical energy is enough to progress three warmth units into the home. Heat pumps are also preferable if you don’t have access to natural gas because they run on electricity. However, one disadvantage of the heat pump is when the temperature outdoors drops below freezing, your heat pump efficiency suffers, and you will require frequent furnace repair in The Villages.

Heat Pump V/S Furnace: Which Produces More Heat?

Heat pumps are less common than furnaces, and most individuals are unfamiliar with them. Traditionally, a furnace creates heat by combusting oil or natural gas and then distributing the heat throughout the house and using electricity to get power. 

On the other hand, heat pumps do not use a form of energy to produce heat. Instead, they transfer heat from the outside to the inside using electricity and coolant. Heat pumps, in essence, serve as both air conditioners during summers and heating systems during winters. 

Heat pump V/S Furnace: Which is More Efficient?

Old furnace models were known for being ineffective, but technological innovation has led to excellent furnace efficiency rates of up to 98 percent. It means that when ignition fumes get vented to the outside, only 2% of the fuel consumed escapes.

Heat pumps can be up to 300% productive because they relocate heat with electricity, using only one electricity entity to move three components of heat energy. However, as you might expect, performance deteriorates as the weather gets colder. Therefore, it necessitates the inclusion of a less efficient heat source in heat pumps when the temperature decreases below freezing.

Which is More Reasonable: A Heat Pump or a Furnace?

If your home has access to natural fuel and combustibles, a furnace system is the most suitable option. However, if your home does not have oil and gas pipelines, a heat pump is a better option. 

Electricity is more costly than natural gas, but heat pumps are more productive than electric furnaces, so you’ll save cash with an electrically heated pump instead of an electric furnace. In addition, it is also the more cost-effective alternative if you’re considering replacing your heating unit, as the heat pump can replace the old one. 

Heat Pumps V/S Furnace.

Here are some points of distinction between a heat pump and a furnace. 

  • Cost

When distinguishing between a heat pump and a furnace, one of the first questions that homeowners will ask is which is more costly. To begin with, your expenses will get determined by what your home already has. 

A furnace may be more inexpensive for homes with direct access to natural gas. A home without natural gas, on the other hand, will almost certainly pay more to have a furnace installed. However, if all other factors are equal, a heat pump is usually less expensive.

  • Repairs

While both heat pump and furnace necessitate regular maintenance, a furnace’s maintenance cost is lesser than a heat pump’s. As a result, your heat pump’s long-term maintenance requirements will also be higher.

  • Effectiveness

Depending on your home’s location, the performance gap between a heat pump and a furnace varies 

significantly. Also, you must keep in mind that, unlike furnaces, heat pumps only transmit heat from the outside. Therefore, a heat pump will probably work much better in mild temperatures. 

That isn’t to say that a heat pump won’t work in cooler regions. A heat pump can pull heat from the outside even when it’s below freezing. However, the heat pump will face difficulty transferring heat when the temperature drops. On the other hand, a furnace will continue to produce heat even in freezing environments.

  • Energy Consumption

The fuel efficiency of a heating system is one of its most appealing features. As previously stated, furnaces produce heat, whereas heat pumps only transmit it. As a result, heat pumps use a lot less energy to function. In addition, heat pumps must work even harder than furnaces to keep your place warm in the winter. Therefore, a heater may be more fuel-efficient if you live in a cold environment.

  • Life Expectancy

A well-maintained gas furnace can last up to 20 years or longer. Even a well-maintained heating system heater, on the other hand, will last around 15 years. As a result, a furnace’s anticipated lifespan increases.

Are you looking for professional technicians for your furnace or heat pump repair in The Villages, FLLook no further than Suter Air Conditioning. 

At  Suter Air Conditioning, we are a team of professional experts and can help you save money on your new heating unit. To book an appointment, call us at (352) 748-3344 or drop us a line at [email protected]